Atlantis Taverna
239 E Main St, Sun Prairie, WI, 53590
Atlantis Taverna Menu
Sorry, We are updating this restaurant menu details.
Visit below restaurant in Sun Prairie for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Sun Prairie for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Sun Prairie for healthy meals suggestion.
Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.
Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.
-
Address :
239 E Main St
Sun Prairie, WI, 53590 - Phone (608) 837-5700
- Website https://www.atlantistaverna.com
- Click To Get Directions
Opening Hours
- Mon :Closed
- Mon : Closed
Tue
Specialities
- Takes Reservations : Yes
Delivery : No
Take-out : Yes
Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
Good For : Dinner
Parking : Street
Bike Parking : Yes
Wheelchair Accessible : No
Good for Kids : Yes
Good for Groups : Yes
Attire : Casual
Ambience : Casual
Noise Level : Average
Alcohol : Full Bar
Outdoor Seating : Yes
Wi-Fi : No
Has TV : No
Waiter Service : Yes
Caters : No
Categories
Greek Cuisine
Greek food is a fine melody of the finest pressed olive oil, fresh fermented bread, colorful vegetables, juicy meat, sea food all cooked in spices and fresh rosemary. The people from Greek were great scholars who aimed to excel in everything they do. The results are quite visible in their food as they are the inventors of olive oil which is beneficial to health. Greeks also made different type of wines from the best quality of grapes fermented in controlled environment.
Today, you can find hundreds of restaurants offering authentic Greek food or popularly termed as Mediterranean cuisine in New York city alone. People wait in line to taste the exotic Greek dishes like saganaki, taramasalata, souvlaki, loukoumades, spanakopita, moussaka, and many more. One thing which most people like about these authentic Greek dishes is abundant use of lemon juice, olive oil, fresh rosemary and sea salt. A smart mix of few ingredients can virtually take you on the pebble streets of beautiful city of Greece.
For those who don't have time to enjoy fine dining should try tasting the famous souvlaki with pita which is type of meat dish, also a trademark Greek fast food. For those who are vegetarian, or vegan can try different versions of Greek Salad. So, if you wish to enjoy a hearty yet healthy meal that tastes divine then try dining at the best Greek restaurant in your city. Greek cuisine not only tastes good but also help maintain your body in a natural way through healthy diet.
WE SERVE THE FOLLOWING STATES
Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online
Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.
Jason M.
Really liked this place. The salads are huge and delicious. Gyros and souvlaki are great too.
(4)Fei X.
Great food. Prices are moderate for the local Greek biz in the neighborhood.
(3)Bret J.
Each time here I left happy! Great food, great service, great choices. This is a can't miss choice
(4)Heather C.
Decided to go here again, cuz humans believe in second chances. This time we went around 2pm, and we sat in a booth instead of the wicker chairs. It was much more comfortable and cozy. At that time of the day we were the only customers, so the problematic acoustics reverberating the sound of one thousand voices was absent. I had the butternut squash pie, that came with a side salad and a pita with dill dipping sauce. It was delish. My dining companion on this day was the minor, who decided to have a cheeseburger. Said cheeseburger got a thumbs up. Now I shall delight you all with what we had next. We decided to be really bad and share a slice of the Golden Harvest Carrot Cake. When I took the very first bite I immediately noticed that time seemed to slow down. My faced warmed and my eyes watered up with tears of extreme joy, all the world looked liked I was viewing it through a slow drip of molasses. I couldn't really say much, but I definitely let out some moans that very well could have been misconstrued by the staff. When I came to, I was mashing my my fork against an empty plate, as was the minor. I also noticed some crumbs laying around the plate on the table, to which I suddenly said with great urgency "get the crumbs! Get the crumbs!" So minor and I threw caution to the wind and vacuumed up the remaining crumbs of carrot cake off the table like dirty little monkeys. After that we sat there and giggled and marveled at the awesomeness of the carrot cake. We would've smoked cigarettes but they don't allow smoking inside.
(4)Tamara C.
This is a very quaint place - the walls are full of colorful murals. The waiting staff is wonderful and attentive. Even when ordering take-out, they offer you a soda or water as you wait. The dishes I've tried (a taste of Taverna) and their gyros are fantastic. Definitely a stop worth while.
(4)Kai D.
Amazing Greek food! Best Gyros in the area! I have eaten here many times, and every time the food seems to get better! The wait staff is very friendly, and helpful (When explaining the menu).
(5)Vern P.
Food and atmosphere was very nice. I had the Veggie Combo, which is 3 Falafel patties, hummus, spinach triangle, cheese triangle, cube of feta, dolmades, tomato slices, olives, pita and yogurt cucumber sauce. The food took a while, but was worth it. The place is brightly colored, murals and all painted by owner, as I was told. Great place to eat and all in heart of downtown,.
(5)Rob C.
I'm 40 and I almost said OMG out loud when I tasted their gyro meat and falafel sampler. Froma friend, the wife and I got a side of the red pepper Tadzhiki, oh yeah that's so good. I really want to go back soon, we drove from Verona for this place, best Greek food I've ever had. I now dream of Greek genie's with falafel sammy's with red pepper Tadzhiik, oh yeah! And they have the best ouzo and lemonade cocktail ever!
(5)Srita C.
Again, one of those good Mediterranean places you will want to go back to. We've ordered here twice and both times we got it to-go. Their service has been fast both times. Another place where I loved the Tzatziki sauce - thicker than most places but tastes very good. What we ordered: Spinach pie - 4.5 Really good. Both times a hit! Chicken Souvlaki - 3.5 3 for the chicken kebab. 3.5 for the green beans and tomato. (With the tomatoes I got the taste like they were canned tomatoes) 5 for the Tzatziki sauce. Veggie Combo - 4 4 for the herby crunchy flavored falafel. 3.5 for the hummus. Thicker than most places but good taste. 4 for the spinach, and cheese triangles though I liked the spinach better. 3.5 for the dolmades this time because the leaves were a bit tough to chew. 5 for the Tzatziki. 5 for the tomatoes, feta and olives! Overall we'll give it a 3.5 because the chicken could have tasted better and the green beans and tomato didn't taste fresh (though they had some good flavor) Service - 4 Both times order was fast and friendly Price - for the portions served I think reasonable $$
(3)Gary D.
What a great find! If you like good Greek food at very reasonable prices this is the place for you. I was in the area on business and whenever I travel I pull out the trusty yelp app and look for something good and wasn't disappointed at all. I started with a glass of french pinot...normally it's $6.50 a glass and it's a decent wine for that price, however double bonus. It was Tuesday night and wine is half price! I'll take 2! I had the Greek combination platter with a Greek side salad and wow what a lot of good food. It included gyro meat, pita slices, the spinach pie, a couple of dolmades, yum! All for 11 bucks. They have a nice little deck in the back to eat outside! The server was very freindly and accomodating. Couldn't ask for more. Check it out!
(4)Brian J.
Great food in a nice setting. I have visited them many times and the food and service is always consistent. A great place to take date! Plenty of parking lot space in back. They are located on main street in down town sun prairie.
(5)Mitch L.
Wow! Just finished another meal at Atlantis Taverna and it was spectacular. I had the Greek salad and gyro combination and my wife had the Tilapia, rice, and vegetable kabobs. Both of them were perfectly prepared and delicious. The gyros here are the best I've had in the Madison area. If you love Greek food put this on your list.
(5)Dan L.
One simple explanation... Great food in small town environment restaurant. This was some of the best Mediterranean food I've had in the area and the relaxed personality of the restaurant made a great impromptu dinner.
(4)Morgan H.
I have been here twice since moving to the area. Both times I was pleasantly surprised with the service and food! My husband raves about how it is very similar to being in Greece.
(5)Ross R.
Been here twice-the gyros are good-had a friend from Greece who told me In Greece gyros are 75 percent lamb & 25 percent beef, in America it's the opposite. If you are ordering for two, don't consider one with extra meat-you will be disappointed. It's too much meat, not enough pita bread. They are are also very stingy with the tomatoes & onions Pricey, not a good value. Staff is indifferent at best. Not a great experience overall, but I will be back, because we love gyros.
(3)Dr. J C.
Great Greek food at a good price. I'm glad they are close enough to allow repeat visits. Matter of fact if it were not for Atlantis Taverna I don't think I would have found this section of Sun Prairie. Weird but true, I never went down Main St farther than Salvatores Tomato Pies before this visit to Atlantis Taverna. Good Eats.
(4)Brian O.
This place is amazing. Incredible food, so authentic, everything cooked with fresh ingredients on site. Super friendly staff that feel like family. Nice drink selections. Really nice atmosphere to dine in. Love this place to death.
(5)John B.
Have been here over 10 times in the past three years. Food is good - especially the dips and tzatziki sauce. Pitas are fresh and always served warm. Good wine list, featuring some interesting Greek wines. (I love Retsina, and they offer a good pour.) Service has been very good to excellent. They get 5 stars from me because of the value - prices are reasonable and portions pleasantly big, not outrageous. If you like good food, this is a solid choice that has never disappointed. (Just wish they regularly made taramosalata. I can understand it is an acquired taste and apparently not for everybody. Maybe if they gave samples next time they make a batch they can create more fans. When they have it, it is always excellent. If you like fish, this roe whipped with lemon and olive oil typically, is light and smooth and offers a slightly salty, nicely "fishy" flavor that will make you think of the ocean.
(5)Dan S.
I have nothing but nice things to say about Atlantis Taverna. Not only are their gyros some of the best I've had (I've had a lot of gyros in my day), the service is great as well. Our first experience was dining in, and the atmosphere was cozy and inviting. Our waitress was helpful with helping us make our decisions, and everything was delivered promptly. We've yet to venture away from gyros (they're that good!), but everything that was brought out to other tables looked delicious as well. Most of our experience now is through takeout, and the food has always been ready and warm, somehow quicker than I can call in an order, put shoes on, and get there. Bravo.
(5)Timothy G.
Been here several times, and everything I've had is very good. The gyros are up there with the best I've had. Hummus and falafel are pretty good, though I've had better. The spanakopita, stuffed grape leaves, and chicken/lamb dishes are all delicious. I assume their baklava is made in-house, but their other desserts, I suspect are brought in. The place is cozy and nicely decorated. Generally much nicer than you'd expect for Sun Prairie. Service has been hit or miss. If you get one of the owners, the service will be fantastic. But some of the other staff are not very good - bored and apathetic like a Denny's server at 2am, though still "trying" in a basic sense. This is where the "Sun Prairie" creeps into the picture. Not horrible, just shrug-worthy. Still, wouldn't stop me from going back.
(4)Jennifer F.
Prepare to be underwhelmed-by the food and the service. I can buy better hummus at the grocery store, and everything else was just lacking in much flavor. Service was completely absent. Didn't check to see how food was, get water refills, and was generally ignored. I love Greek food but am not eager to come back.
(2)Becky D.
Can't recommend this place enough - delicious food, friendly service, charming decor. Best gyros in the area. Spicy lamb wrap is amazing - everything is just excellent.
(5)Anne E.
this was literally the best gyro I have ever had. right here in sun prairie, wisconsin. the falafel appetizer was delicious and obviously fresh. they have a good thing going here.... we're already planning our next trip back. yum! not to mention, the awesome price point. :)
(5)Tonja B.
Stopped in per recommendations from Yelp for business dinner. LIZ served us and what a gracious soul she was. The food was absolutely wonderful. Had the lamb kabobs and my other guests were very happy also as everything was awesome. They tried the moussaka and pastitsio and it was to die for. Don't forget the baklava!! I highly recommend and your in for a treat if you get Liz for a server. I felt like part of their family before I left.
(5)David M.
8/25/13 Taking some local advice we stopped in to the Atlantis Taverna to continue our anniversary celebrations. We took in their outdoor balcony. The grape leaves were tasty (served cold as indicated per the menu). The salad was nice. The 3 meat entree was good. Bell's Two Hearted Ale went perfectly with everything. I think it's better than Plaka Taverna, but try both for yourself. I thought they used far less salt.
(3)Jeff L.
Had dinner recently with a group of friends at Atlantis Taverna on Main Street in Sun Prairie. I quite enjoyed my meal. We had several orders of saganak (flaming greek cheese. Opa!) as an appetizer. I had pastitsio (which is like greek lasagne) and a bowl of avgolemono soup (egg and lemon cream with chicken and rice in it. Sounds bizarre but is very good when made correctly, and Atlantis does a good job). I enjoyed coffee and baklava and a Point Root beer for desert. I will definately be going back.
(5)Marlene M.
Amazing gyros! They serve you an awesome amount of meat and the perfect amount of sauce. The onion slices aren't cut too thick and everything all together just tastes amazing. This is my #1 spot for gyros! Every time I've been to this place they've never seem too busy. The service is quick and efficient. I'll be sure to come back!
(5)Jim H.
Simply Awesome. I first went there when they opened in Sun Prairie. I loved it, but I didn't think they would last simply because almost nothing does. A few years later they are here and going strong. I have had just about everything on the menu and I have never once been disappointed. Especially with the dolmades. I'm a sucker for dolmades. If you want a light atmosphere in a cozy restaurant and the finest Greek food in Southern Wisconsin, go to Atlantis Taverna. We go every couple of weeks, and when a kitchen experiment fails, it's off to Atlantis for some food. Do yourself a favor and stop in, try a sampler plate or a gyro, or the spanikopita. Anything. Your tastebuds will love you for it.
(5)A.D. M.
Best Greek food in the area. I love the Parthenon on State Street, but that's Greek fast food. This place is more traditional and does theme nights, which are a lot of fun. Have a shot of ouzo.
(5)Madison F.
Great restaurant in SP! The salads are amazing, hummus very good. Enjoy the owners !
(5)Dave O.
The service is fantastic! Kristin always remembers our Favorite menu items. Food is very tasty & atmosphere is very enjoyable.
(5)Martha B.
We LOVE Atlantis. My husband and I have been dining at Atlantis since at least 2007. I lived in Chicago most of my life, and the food at Atlantis is as good as the best restaurants in Greektown. (But we haven't eaten at Plaka in Madison, which is "closely related" to Atlantis.) I'm a vegetarian and Atlantis offers a ton of great veggie choices - not always an option when you're outside of Madison proper. The hummus, Spanikopita and Squash pie are all amazing. My husband loves the olive stuffed meatballs. The prices are incredibly reasonable, and the orange cake is a fabulous way to end your meal. Atlantis has a reward program too, so if you dine there with any regularity you can save some on your meals over time. They also do special small plate events every so often, which give you a great chance to try a lot of different dishes.
(5)Dawn O.
You can never go wrong if you're looking for Mediterranean food. Beth and her staff are excellent. We usually order for takeout it's always hot and ready and delicious every time. I highly recommend this restaurant in Sun Prairie.
(5)Kelly T.
First time visit yesterday. I stopped in thinking I'd get carry out, but decided to eat in by myself to avoid the hassle. Unfortunately, the hostess said, "only one?!" in a judgmental way which turned me off, but wait service made up for it. Why do some hostesses still make solo diners feel like pariahs in this era? Anyhoo, the food was great! The saganaki was good, but not the best I've had. They serve it with beer bread, which I didn't care for at all; so I asked for pita. For the entree, I ordered the spanakopita and falafel combo. Holy moly, seriously good! Good thing I was solo because the garlic woulda killed any dinner companion, but it was all soooo good! I would have preferred the spanakopita with a bit more feta, but some feta on the side solved that, and the falafel.... Truly as good as I've had in Greece and the Middle East. The hummus and tzatziki sauce were excellent! Could have eaten a platter of their soft, fluffy pitas (but probably not homemade like nearly everything on their menu) with just the tatzicki and hummus alone. Had so much food left over, and added a delicious Greek custard pastry to go - made for an outstanding lunch today! Would love it if they'd throw me a few kalamata olives on my plate next time! On top of it, my waitress was charming and attentive. I'll be back, and you should too. Try some Greek wine while you're at it, and say "OPA!"
(4)Dave R.
We ate here for the first time yesterday evening and enjoyed the food and the atmosphere. The gyros, spanikopita, falafel, warmed pita bread and humus were all very good. Our excellent waitress suggested the white sangria which we also enjoyed.
(5)Clement H.
Left a review under my name as well. Just thinking about that Gyro and wanting to give you another five stars! Absolutely delicious!
(5)Tony D.
Great place with nice atmosphere and wonderful service. The gyro meat is the most tender lamb/beef mix I have ever had and my wife and I LOVE gyros. Their tzatziki sauce is very good as well. We particularly enjoy the hummus and 3 dip plate appetizer. I wouldn't recommend the Pastisio (Greek lasagna) or Moussaka. The flavors of the dishes just don't seem to come together.
(4)Bill P.
Very good best gyro in sun praire
(5)Clement H.
Stopped in to pick up a to-go gyro dinner for four. It was fantastic! The meat was juicy and had great flavor and the pitas were soft and warm. Cucumber sauce was tasty as well. Gladly recommend this place to anyone searching for a great gyro at a reasonable price.
(5)Incognito W.
I think the only thing I agree with from a previous reviewer was that "the staff was nice". I loved the food and the atmosphere here. I had a gyro as part of some combo, and found it to be a good size. Every time I've gone to Atlantis Taverna I've left satisfied, or overstuffed from their portions. I've gone there with large parties of people and everyone has enjoyed their food and never noticed any issues with hearing people talk. It's a good family-run restaurant, with excellent greek choices beyond the basic gyro, (including some vegetarian choices) and is definitely worth the drive out to SP.
(4)Jody M.
Thought we'd try something a bit different. It was ok but I probably won't make the drive out there again. Service and ambience was great during the lunch hour.
(3)Rebecah M.
The staff was lovely, and although the paintwork is garish and the seats are uncomfortable, it was a surprisingly cozy restaurant. Nice selection of specialty sodas which is fun. I had the chicken wrap with fries and it was delicious. The chicken was moist and the sauce was wonderful. The fries were to die for. I got the specialty custard pastry for desert and it was delightful. Downtown Sun Prairie is small, but nice and there were some cute shops I would like to visit when I have more time.
(4)E H.
I've never had a bad meal there. I've also never seen it packed, which is too bad. They don't skimp on the gyros, which is good. Order extra pita bread if you get a gyro. You'll want it.
(5)Chris D.
Great food. Great atmosphere. Our family likes to come here once a year or so when we get that hankering for some good Greek food.
(4)Stacey O.
I would give this more like 3.5 stars, but since you can't do half... good food, cute place, no complaints.
(4)Melissa S.
Great Gyros here!! Service has been great and great value for your $$$.
(4)